| Year | Golfer of the Year | 2nd place | 3rd place |
| 2021 | Jim Kane | Bill Keagle | Don Morrison |
| 2020 | Jim Wetzel | Jim Kane | Bill Keagle |
| 2019 | Bob Castagnera | Ed Senseney | Drew Bonthron |
| 2018 | Joe Mellor | Bill Keagle | Earl Addicks |
| 2017 | Bill Keagle | Drew Bonthron | Don Morrison |
| 2016 | Cal Miller | Earl Addicks | Bob Castagnera |
| 2015 | Tom D. Ferrara | Tom M. Ferrara | Terry Castagnera |
| 2014 | Cal Miller | Jon Coonan | Rich Dunnigan |
| 2013 | Tom M. Ferrara | Tom D. Ferrara | Drew Bonthron |
| 2012 | Tom D. Ferrara | Bill Fosnaught | Tom M. Ferrara |
| 2011 | Bob Beahm | Drew Bonthron | Tom M. Ferrara |
| 2010 | no record | ||
| 2009 | Bill Barnes | Bill Keagle | Jim Wetzel |
| 2008 | Jim Wetzel & Terry Castagnera (tie) | Bob Castagnera | |
| 2007 | Jim Wetzel | Drew Bonthron | Bill Keagle |